해리 포터 대 트와일라잇 Club
가입하기
Fanpop
New Post
Explore Fanpop
I read the twilight saga and i loved it i was a twihard for a while yes, but was 더 많이 fond of the voltori than anything else, When i read Harry Potter and the philosophers stone, i became addicted in its content, i read the 책 one 의해 one and read them again, i like twillight, yes, but there is no doubt i prefar Harry Potter, i also read all the Hunger Games 책 and was a tribute, still Harry Potter is my life and soul. Jk.rowling has an imagnation unlike many i know, the 책 depth and detail is unbelivable, i just wish it never had to end, 당신 have to read all the 책 또는 당신 wont fully...
continue reading...
posted by RonGetYourWand
10
Here is a list of flaws found in Twilight:

1. Quileute Tribe - She added imprinting, which isn't even in their history, as a way to manipulate the relationships and have automatic 'true love' . If I was Quileute I would feel insulted.

link

link

2. Basic Biology - It is stated in New Moon that an ancestor of the Quileute tribe transferred his soul to a real 늑대 when his earthly body had been destroyed. In Breaking Dawn, Edward reveals that the Quileute tribe are not real werewolves, but shape-shifters. How can it be that this transformation is genetic for the descendants of the tribe?

3. Armed forces...
continue reading...
Both twilight and harry potter are very successful, especially among teenagers. Some people keep arguing about which is better, though in my opinion, THEY SHOULDN'T BE COMPARED!

Now, i have to admit i 사랑 both series! I'd say harry potter is unisex and appropriate for all ages, whilst twilight adresses mainly to teenage girls. HP talks about friendship and love, while twilight is 더 많이 romantic! Also, hp gives lessons of life, although maybe in some cases, i would prefer 읽기 twilight.

Finally, They are both written 의해 two very talented and imaginative writers, j.k rowling and stephenie meyer. They wrote these 책 to give teens (and not only) inspiration and time of happiness. So, if 당신 don't like one of these two series, don't blame them! We can't all have the same tastes!
posted by one_a_kind4ever
3
In my last 기사 I got some 코멘트 that stated that I didn't support my opinion so I will try again.

Harry Potter is definitely going to be a story that people are going to be telling 50 years from now. Harry Potter is a fun filled story taking place in a wizarding world as many of 당신 know. Over the past couple of years it has been argued that Twilight is better. Us Harry Potter 팬 disagree because a 17 년 old wizard who defeats a dark lord is WAY better than a sparkling 107 년 old vampire virgin. I respect the fact that Twilight has 팬 as well that like Twilight for reasons we...
continue reading...
well,
copied from a web-site:


Great:
Wizard-on-wizard combat in the films
Writing battle scenes was never Rowling’s strongest suit, but her fight scenes became electric on the screen, 더 많이 또는 less literally: The effect when two thrown spells locked in mid-air is particularly splashy and creative, with the clash of energy throwing off heavy, wet detritus that looks like paint. Scenes like the Battle For Hogwarts at the end of the series, the Ministry Of Magic showdown in Order Of The Phoenix (with good and evil wizards zipping around as light and dark clouds, and the sense that 더 많이 action was...
continue reading...
Lesson 1: PROPS!!! Lots and lots of props!




Harrypotterlurvfeverweasley_ravenclar-granger gave me props for my comments:
“Hi I really like the way 당신 verbally attack Twilight fans. The way 당신 threatened their lives 의해 tracking down their IP address and sending them cryptic letter describing how you’re going to kidnap them in their sleep and dismember them limb 의해 limb was so cool. Don’t worry; I’ll have your back if they call the police. I know you’re totally justified because I hate that book too.”


Cullenlife_number1fan_forks gave me props for my articles:
“Hey, that wasn’t fair,...
continue reading...
Not sure what to 제목 this exactly:P

Anyways this was a 코멘트 on some 포럼 here I cant remember and I liked it so decided to post it as an article. It was 의해 Lumos_Maxima I believe.


You have Robert Pattison play Edward - we had him play Cedric. He even admitted to enjoying play Cedric 더 많이 than Edward ;)

You have Jacob and Edward - we have Draco Malfoy and Blaise Zabini.

You have Bella 백조 - we have Bellatrix Lestrange who could Avada Kedavra your Bella any day.

You have Jacob Black - we have Remus Lupin who is the real werewolf here. Jacob isn't even a werewolf, he's a shape shifter.

You have...
continue reading...
posted by mr-cullen
5
NOTE:copied from web site.
if same 기사 is there tell me i will remove this

1) Sperm are living cells that need to be reproduced. If 당신 have been dead for a hundred years such as Edward Cullen your sperm would be LONG dead. Also sperm needs protein, something Edwards body has no need for. If Edward has no sperm, how did he conceive Renessme?

2) 23 and 24 chromosomes does not produce a healthy off spring. Nessie either had a genetic disorder would of died.

3) If Jasper shouldn't of been around people why did he go to school. The Cullen family lived in the middle of no where. I'm sure they could...
continue reading...
posted by spongebob105
17
Did 당신 ever think that dumbledore was useing harry potter? Well he did! As 당신 can see in snape's thoughts that he did. Dumbledore said that he was like a pig up for slauter! I mean who is mean to say that 또는 act twards that person. WELL HE DID!



He doesn't realy think about what would he feel if he was steping into his shoes. I mean come on. He thinks he so COOL that he has the elder wand. HE'S A NORMAL PERSON FOR CRYING OUT LOUD!


Well now getting back to the subject. Dumbledore is a MEAN person so if 당신 want to find out your self then go to chapter that says "Snape's Memories"
-Spongebob105
posted by DracoLuver
18
Hello everyone!

I'm planning on 글쓰기 a letter to Stephenie Meyer regarding the Twilight series. I wanted to address all the points many people do not like in the series. The letter is going to be friendly and straight-forward. I wanted to hear what everyone would want me to include. These are a few of the topics I am going to be including:

- Anti-feminism
- Abusive relationship
- Unhealthy obsession
- Lust does not equal 사랑
- Bella is horribly rude to her 프렌즈 (not valued friendships)

These are just a few. Please add anything and if there is something specific you'd like me to add.

I'll be working on this letter and posting on Sunday on Fanpop, so I can add anything else and have your approval and then I will send it to her.
I understand that Seth probably won't let it get to her, but it's worth a shot and I will post his reply (assuming he does reply.)

Thank you! :)
posted by june13
3
we all knowed hermiones was one of harrys 프렌즈 anyone who did not know her know her for a know it all over the years at hogwards she larned not to worry want everyone says about 당신 and want 당신 are in book five six and 7 we was showed want she could do that was not spells and every thing esl 사랑 she fell hard for one boy that was her freind ron and some us thougth that i =t was going to be harry 또는 nelive over the ages she had kids and they turn out to be smart and good at hogwards to and we all thought that she would end up somewhere esl on the road
I thought this would be fun!Guess what!?What if I had an interview with J.K. Rowling and Stephanie Meyer together!This is the fake interview with me,J.K. Rowling,and Stephanie Meyer:
----------------------
Me:Welcome,Stephanie.Welcome,J.K.
Rowling:Hello.
Meyer:Hi.
M:Are 당신 ready for the interview?
R:Yeah,Stephanie.
Stephanie:Yes.
M:Ok,since 당신 both write fiction-how did 당신 come up with the books?
S.M.:It was a dream,the meadow scene and I woke up and I'm like,"How did they get their?How did they fall in love?WHat would happen,next?"I jumped out of 침대 and sat down and started writing.Going,"I can't...
continue reading...
Harry Potter beats Twilight. Of course. But I really don't like it when HP 팬 use opinion-ated "facts" when saying WHY Harry Potter is the better movie series. So, I, who am a major Potterhead, put together 7 true, solid, hard, and undeniable facts about certain aspects of the two movie series to prove why Harry Potter is the ultimate series.
**I will only be discussing the movies**

1) Soundtrack

Listen to this wonderful and memorable theme song. As 당신 may have guessed, the theme song belogs to Harry Potter : link

Now listen to this: link
It's pretty, but it doesn't find a special place in...
continue reading...
posted by HopeEve
8
ok so I found this stupid person listing all the reasons why twilight is better than twilight. so I replied to every single one. and this is her picture:





1. Robert Pattinson, can 당신 say HOT? And he's totally sexy when he sparkles!

So? Hotness has absolutely no correlation to 연기 ability. He was also in Harry Potter first.


2. Taylor Lautner, I mean, have 당신 SEEN those muscles?

NOT HOT. Strange nose, closed up eyes and no 연기 ability. That is just my personal opinion. As I said, hotness has no correlation to 연기 ability.

3. Kristen Stewart. An extremely talented and beautiful actress,...
continue reading...
When me and my friend Fiona were in the sixth grade, we decided to write a fanfiction about the Twilight characters going to Hogwarts. (We were both major Twilight 팬 then.) I wasn't the best writer in those days, so the beginning of the fanfic isn't great, but it gets better as we go along.
You'll notice that our seprate entries can get a bit confusing at times, and that's because we were 글쓰기 의해 e-mail because she lives six hours away from me, and we were just making it up as we went along. Fiona is 글쓰기 about the character Peace, and I am using the character that I use for EVERYTHING,...
continue reading...
posted by LoveforSeverus
21
Alright I haven't gotten a chance to revise and 편집 this so it's still kind of a list type thing. I guess I'll finish later. One point for now.


While 읽기 the 인기 teen book Twilight, I couldn't help but notice some rather disturbing problems, and some facts that just don't add up.

For starters, Twilight is anti feminist. How can it be anti-feminist? 당신 might ask. Well here's how, Bella is always staying at 집 tending to either her father, her boyfriend, 또는 her boyfriends family. Meyer cleverly disguises this 의해 saying "oh well Charlie can't cook" and "there's nothing better to do"....
continue reading...
posted by Mrs-Grint
30
 As 당신 can see, some of his Niffler genes are actually visible. If you'll look to his stomach...
As you can see, some of his Niffler genes are actually visible. If you'll look to his stomach...
OK, so many Harry Potter/vampire 팬 (like myself) will probably agree that Edward Cullen is not a real vampire. The only similarities that Edward and other 뱀파이어 have is the liking of human blood. I suppose Meyer was trying to be original, and I don't mean to offend anyone who does like the sparklepyres.

Why Edward Cullen is a niffler

Before I state my actual reasons, I should probably tell anyone who doesn't know what a niffler actually is. For this I have my trusty Fantastic Beasts and Where To Find Them book:

NIFFLER
M.O.M. Classification: XXX [Which means a competent wizard should cope...
continue reading...
posted by Sophia21
37
Ah well, in the name of justice now I will take it a little bit against Harry Potter. For starters I will only mention consistency errors 또는 plot mistakes. Scientific and lore mistakes will be included later. HEY! They are 7 very long books, and unlike Twilight were mistakes were easy to spot amongst the constant lovey-dovey of Bella and Edward, Harry Potter has a lot of information going around. Now then.

1)Where did Voldemort stick his wand?
Explanation: Yeah the 제목 doesn't give a very nice image. But seriously. Voldemort went on a solo mission to kill the Potters and their baby. Due to...
continue reading...
Okay so I've come to realize how all of this is just pointless. People seem to only compare Twilight and Harry Potter because the two are popular. That is a main reason why those two are being compared now. Now to me I have really found this to be pointless. People are comparing a romantic fiction story to a 판타지 fiction story.

Now when I realized this is when a 코멘트 was made 의해 a user who goes 의해 the name: justmandi23
on the topic "1000 reasons why twilight is better than harry potter" So what she wrote just made me realize what I did. I 게시됨 like a lot of reasons in the topic, "1000...
continue reading...
posted by KateKicksAss
27
NOTE: This interview is written as if Bella is still human. Think after Eclipse but before Breaking Dawn. And I don't mean to offend Twilight 팬 with any of the 질문 that Rita asks Bella in this article, based on Rita's personality in the books, I'm assuming she'd ask awkward questions.

Me Myself and I
By Rita Skeeter

Today's interview is with 인기 판타지 book character, Bella Swan. Captivating readers in Twilight, read on as I interview Bella, and see if there's 더 많이 to her than just an obsession with Edward!

*The door opens, and in walks Bella......with Edward.*

Bella Swan: Can...
continue reading...