i loved all the episode 5 songs, sweet caroline, take a bow and obvvvv dont stop believin!

Does 'Ride Wit Me' count? That was way smaller, but it was definitely one of my favorites.

yes thats why i left it open to add on ones like ride with me and the solos and auditions all the short songs!

Do you know how long it took me to pick my final answer? Nearly twenty minutes. No joke. I went through a whole process of elimination, which I will guide you through:

First to go: Thong Song, You Just Keep Me Hangin On, No Air, Rehab, I Say A Little Prayer, Take A Bow, Mercy, This Is How We Do It, Poison, Tonight, and Alone.

Next to leave: Bust A Move, Sweet Caroline, Last Name, and Push It.

Last minute I decided the two Mercedes numbers were out-- Bust Your Windows and Hate On Me.

Now the REAL decision making began.
I played the first minute of each remaining song to my mom and I, since I was in desperate need of help.
After listening, I took out the boys & girls mash-ups, Maybe This Time, and Taking Chances.

I grudgingly plucked Keep Holding On from the mix.
Gold Digger & I Wanna Sex You Up went home together to trash talk about me for taking them out of the running so close to the finals (yes, all these songs have feelings and I'm breaking all their hearts...)

So. Somebody To Love and Don't Stop Believing. I listened to both songs again. Stewed in silence. And tapped my little laptop mouse pad on option of...

Don't Stop Believing!!! My grand prize winner!!!

Lol, Cat! Just...lol! :D

'It's My Life' is my absolute favorite song from these, so I had to pick it.

Don't Stop Believing, Sweet Caroline, Taking Chances, Keep Holding on and Somebody to Love :)

I'm surprised this wasn't up there, so I added it. This is definitely my fave, I'm almost 100% sure they sang it live.

I just really wanted Puck to sing :)

yeah sorry i was really tired when i did it and i couldnt be bothered going back and adding it after renrae said it! lol

it was almost impossible to choose!!!!!!!!!

wow, this was so hard to choose. i loved somebody to love and don't stop believin', they will probably always be my favorite performances because i loved how they sang it and the choreography was amazing. but i also liked sweet caroline just because of the fact that puck sang it and he did it so great. it's my life/confessions was hilarious. i also liked alone, i think it was so much better than the original but in the show they only sang a very short version and there wasn't really anything spectacular about the performance but the song was awesome!

Puck, singin' Puck, singin' Puck with the guitar - three best elements together. Have I mentioned Puck yet?

Most absolutely followed by It's My Life/Confessions. Artie's solo is awesome.

And I say a little prayer 4 u