이 질문에 답하기

에반에센스 질문

What do 당신 think about 에반에센스 haters?

On the web I saw alot of people that hated 에반에센스 and said that there are a cheap copy of Nightwish,Within Temptation and Lacuna Coil,that 에반에센스 is an 이모 band(they meant 이모 in the stereotypical meaning of the word),that 에반에센스 has crappy lyrics and that Amy has a terrible voice and that she does sing but she whines and they said that 에반에센스 is only a band for teenagers
I personally think that they are idiots but I wanted to know 당신 opinions.What do 당신 think about them?
 SeeWhoIAm posted over a year ago
next question »

에반에센스 답변

rory2011 said:
first of all 에반에센스 are not copying nightwish,within temptation and lacuna coil cause 에반에센스 are better than them the only good just good band bettwen those is within temptation ,they're them selfs all those bands still the same in a bad way not in a good way,I find 에반에센스 have 더 많이 interesting cause each album is different than the other,and 당신 can't expect what they will do next
초 If they think that 에반에센스 are an 이모 band then they don't know what 이모 means (stupid people)
and whats the crappy about 에반에센스 lyrics it's very honest and very true they just saying that cause they don't have anything to say
amy has an amazing voice they have soooooo many great preforamnce that show amy's amazing voice and how did they know that she whines while she singing???
finaly 에반에센스 are not a band just for teens cause the one that introduced me to 에반에센스 is 28years old male
there're teenagers who 사랑 에반에센스 but those teens have a great taste in 음악 and they're creative people, and those who saying that are young teens I knew that kind of people teens act like a grown ups but they have no idea what they talking about and if not then they were teens before ,what's the deal???
and I don't care for what they say I 사랑 evanescenec and they hate them it doesn't matter for me but the funny thing that they have to lie to make for them selfs an excuse to hate them and if they really don't like them then why do they care for them???
I hate tons of band but I don't talke about them except when some one ask me about what I think of them

the only word that I can describe them is jealous
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
totally agree with 당신
SeeWhoIAm posted over a year ago
*
agreed
evanescence_ posted over a year ago
*
I totally agree
324anna posted over a year ago
evanescence_ said:
Well maybe they look like that if you're not inside of their 음악 and everything. Everyone has their own story and memory to every song of a band. People who don't feel the same way can't understand that.
But as long as they don't talk shit about them I don't care if they hate them. I like to be 팬 of bands which no one 엘 know listens to.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
agree,best answer here
rory2011 posted over a year ago
*
thank you!!
evanescence_ posted over a year ago
OliveTheAbove21 said:
everyone's entitled to their opinion, even if it is retarded. :D
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
ArcticWolf said:
Personally, some bands that are frequently being compared to Evanescence I actually prefer, like Within Temptation and Nightwish, because they are a tad 더 많이 interesting to me in both their vocals and use of instruments and have 더 많이 variety from album to album, while some other bands that Ev are compared to, like Lacuna Coil and Xandria, I think are a bit "bland" (but not even remotely dull, don't get me wrong!) compared to stuff Ev have done. I personally like all the bands 당신 listed as examples.

But to clarify, 에반에센스 is NOT copying anyone. They began in 1994 and for the longest time Amy had no idea that the many Europeans bands 에반에센스 was being compared to actually existed. As for songwriting, I think Evanescence's lyrics are better than some bands up there and not as good as others (Nightwish has the best, IMO). Evanescence's lyrics can be dark and almost 고딕 sounding (which is why they are sometimes inaccurately labeled as "gothic rock"), which some people sadly mistake for "emo". (Don't get me started on a rant about how 이모 and goth are nothing alike!) As for 에반에센스 being only for teenagers, many Ev 팬 ARE teenagers, so people immediately jump to the conclusion that the teen age is the only age that it is appropriate to like them. Another reason why people think that is because people generally stereotype darker-ish lyrics as "angsty", which is, again, a stereotype for teenagers. I don't believe it for a 초 because every single member of my family, even family members like uncles and older cousins, all like Evanescence. It really just is a stereotype.

However, I actually kind of understand the hate 에반에센스 gets sometimes. I'm sorry if this will offend anyone, but I don't put Amy's vocals on such a high pedestal as I used to. To me, her voice strains a lot, and although I think Amy really CAN sing, the strains can get irritating and it's obviously not good for her voice, which is one of the reasons why I honestly don't think she's as good as some of the European frontwomen she's constantly being compared to (sorry!). She's gotten much better, though, IMO. In addition to that the band, aside from Amy, hasn't shown much above-average musicianship. Taking both examples into account, can 당신 blame some people when Evanescence, an extremely 인기 rock band world-wide, begins to overshadow other bands that really do have better trained musicians and vocalists? I mean, it's completely out of line and as an 에반에센스 팬 it offends me (I know it may not seem like it right now, but 에반에센스 is in my 상단, 맨 위로 10 가장 좋아하는 bands of all time), but I understand the reasoning behind the hate.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
As a matter of fact Nightwish overshadows every symphonic metal band over and over again and every symphonic metal band is compared to them but they don't get as much hate as 에반에센스 does.
SeeWhoIAm posted over a year ago
*
Well, I don't see how Once becoming 인기 in the United States has much to do with becoming commercial. I'm from the United States, and barely anyone I know has even heard of them. Of course, no genre other than pop seems to get any recognition. Nightwish may be 인기 in other countries, but they're pretty unheard of where I live. And I personally think making fun of someone who likes to listen to bands other than metal is very stupid. If someone only listens to one genre of music, no matter what genre, then I don't think they fully understand what the term "music" means, not to mention it's got to get boring after a while. I guess that's what they can think. I personally like other metal genres like heavy metal, but I really can't imagine my life if that was the only thing I listened to. If those people want to bore themselves 의해 refusing to listen to anything diverse, even something simple like a different subgenre of metal, then so be it. It's entirely their problem.
ArcticWolf posted over a year ago
*
I'm paranoid about offending people because I really *have* offended people in the past. In fact, I'd like to think I've matured since the last argument/debate I was in, but there's always a point where I think I went too far and was too aggressive. (And when I say aggressive, I mean when I first joined 팬팝 I used to try to emphasize my points 의해 PUTTING EVERYTHING IN ALL CAPS, and I'm pretty sure I called someone an idiot, just for examples. I am now very embarrassed 의해 it. xD)
ArcticWolf posted over a year ago
blossomyumyum said:
I have no idea to act serious towards haters, so I'm just like... 'Hi! Heard 당신 disliked Lovely Amy Lee! Does it Look Like I Give?' Yeah, I suck at trying to get mad.. but it does bother me, because I don't see how Amy and Sharon, Lacuana, Hayley, even Flyleaf, are that similar. It's only because they're all 'goth' and girls in a mostly boy band.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Not that I'm saying Hayley Williams is goth, because she isn't in the slightest.
blossomyumyum posted over a year ago
*
I 사랑 this answer right here lol!
ANewWayToBleed posted over a year ago
natasajackson said:
There are 에반에센스 haters,too??

oh,great!

Then,why don't we just start a war and kill each other so it will end at last!!

Cuz if 당신 say that there are 2 sides,the true fans(the lovers) and the haters..
Then what i see is just FREAKS(in general)
Just pathetic people trying to prove something becuz they say so

They don't even know how to argue with someone and most of the times..They don't even know what they say!!

that's why i stay out of fights
i mean..it's insane
No words..I think u got my point
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
yea,I get your point,but I know why some one post this quis here beacuse if 당신 saw the 코멘트 in my 심장 is broken video you'll find one of the haters called niki 또는 something with N start offended 에반에센스 people start talking with him\her why she\he hate 에반에센스 then she\he start saying that trja is better and we're stupid teenagers and making fun of us ,she\he can hate what ever he\she want this is his\her opinion and I respecte it but why did he\she offended us for stupid 음악 taste,I mean we are all human if I have to hate every one hate 에반에센스 that means I'll hate most of the people on earth it's not a big deal to hate some thing but it's a big deal to hate some one cause he\she 사랑 some thing that 당신 don't like
rory2011 posted over a year ago
*
^Oh, that sucks! Tarja 팬 are particularly brutal to Amy Lee, I see it happen a lot...
ArcticWolf posted over a year ago
*
No, no, 당신 didn't offend me at all! :)
ArcticWolf posted over a year ago
girsmurf22 said:
Some people have dumb opinions,ones that nobody cares about,like the people who say that,and ya know what i say to them?

How would u like annice hot cup of i dont give a f%*!

I think they get the message ^W^
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
사랑 ya!You awesome!
EclipseShadow posted over a year ago
hAyLeY12547 said:
Nothing... it's their opinion and their fault that they have no taste in music... and I could also say that Nightwish,Within Temptation and Lacuna Coil are "cheap copies" of 에반에센스 (That was just an example!!!)...
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Just because somebody doesn't like a band 당신 like doesn't mean they have no taste in music.
MasterRed posted over a year ago
Kazybek said:
에반에센스 is a band, that is making the coolest songs, and only 에반에센스 makes songs like this. Haters are envying, that their favourite bands are not like this one.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
EclipseShadow said:
Nightwish and Within Temptation are nothing Compared to Evanescence.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
AGREED.
Tamar20 posted over a year ago
*
Well, I guess opinions are opinions. xD
ArcticWolf posted over a year ago
Tamar20 said:
I just wanna say to them that when Amy Lee starts to sing 당신 shut the fuck up and listen.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
LOL ,you're totally right
rory2011 posted over a year ago
IsidoraSmiley said:
Well,i like 에반에센스 and I don't really hate people who hate them! Everyone has their own taste for everything,after all!
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
para-scence said:
They didn't copy them; those bands are just similar. Just like pop artists didn't copy other pop artists...
And they probably just can't relate on any level to the music. Their loss.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
punkgothdoll said:
I think that people have a right to not personally like them but nobody should hate them
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
Alchemistlover said:
Idiots
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
MJsGurl4Eva1202 said:
I think 에반에센스 haters are fucking dumbass that have no lives and have nothing else better to do and they don't know what real 음악 is. Why does there have to be so many haters? There's haters for 에반에센스 and Michael Jackson and 어셔 and all the good people that actually have a purpose in life. Maybe that's it. These people are haters because they feel they have no purpose in life. THATS IT!!!!!!!
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
sims3titi said:
I don't know,but i 사랑 Evanescence.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
bandismylife said:
Some people just genuinely don't like certain bands and I'm okay with that. I can see how people would think their lyrics sound "emo" 또는 "whiny" if they haven't experienced the things that they're talking about. They really are very depressing subjects like death, self-harm, suicide, abuse, etc. Those are all staples of the 이모 음악 so it's nt unfair to say they are "emo lyrics", and it's not an insult to call something 이모 so that doesn't even count as hate in my book. And I do see similarities between 에반에센스 and Lacuna Coil 또는 Within Temptation (not really Nightwish) but not enough to say that 에반에센스 is a direct copy of any of them. Plus, Amy isn't very good live so I get people who say she isn't a good singer. I prefer her studio voice personally, but everyone has their own opinions and I'm fine with that.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Wow, someone else agrees with me about Amy's live voice. :P
ArcticWolf posted over a year ago
the_lost_heart said:
Burn them.Burn all of them.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
holli123456789 said:
Wow everyone has really long answers...I think 에반에센스 is AMAZING and that's all that matters c:
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
ktichenor said:
To be honest I don't really think about the haters I just enjoy Evanescence's 음악 :)
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
ugh2014 said:
It's a matter of opinion and 당신 are entitled to yours. But a lot of people like 에반에센스 (me included). For any to say any band with a female lead vocalist formed before 또는 after the 90's/00's as a infirior copy to evanecence 또는 vise versa needs to reeducated themselves. 1. 에반에센스 was formed around the mid 90's (94/95 possibly?) as most bands: nightwish (1996), within temptation (1996) , Lacuna Coil (1994) to name a few. For some odd reason these bands espically lacuna coil keep getting that EV copy label dispte the fact LC is 고딕 Metal / Rock while EV is a Rock band (some call them metal but I think they are 더 많이 rock than metal). Also LC has 2 vocalist while EV is just Amy. And since when is 또는 was Amy an operatic vocalist? I know she did some choir in high school but operatic? Really?
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
Landdownunder said:
I absolutely 사랑 에반에센스 and there style of 음악 but the real difference is between those other bands is they managed to become 더 많이 commercialized and there's many pop listeners that listen to them. Amy lee sing very well and has performed with the like of Korn another band i love. But to compare them like a competition 또는 challenge to those other bands is silly. They are special in there own way that's those other bands as I've 사랑 listening to there 음악 as well. I have noticed they are all different from each other. But any true musician 또는 음악 teacher could tell 당신 that, so why compare? My personal 가장 좋아하는 band is Nightwish with Floor Jansen As there 음악 is 시 and they take 당신 on a Journey there songs seem different then anything I've heard even other Symphonic metal bands are great but not the same. And Floor can do any type of 음악 she sets her mind on look ant Beste Zangers you'll see she can sing Opera, Pop Rock just about anything and in many Languages. Including 디즈니 songs like let it go from Frozen. Just because a band appears to be one's 가장 좋아하는 doesn't mean we should dish against other bands. All these bands are great there is no real comparisons as what is my 가장 좋아하는 may not be yours it's freedom of choice. Just Enjoy all these different flavors 음악 has to offer and thank god it's not Pop LOL just kidding.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
AnnaMariapap said:
Actually, the people that say 에반에센스 is not good surely haven't even listened to their songs and they judge from one song they have probably ever heard. It is vital that we mention that 음악 is something subjective. However, lyrics and meaning in lyrics are actually objective, since from them 당신 can realise whether a band 또는 a song is better than others 또는 not. Therefore, it is certain that people that say brutal things about 에반에센스 haven't even paid enough attention to understand their songs. Because if they had, they would have actually noticed songs with deep meanings: songs about social problems and media dominance, songs about fantasy,dream/ reality, about the importance of finding yourself, songs about death, suicide and God, and most importantly songs about mental illnesses and depression. Songs with which millions of people can relate to, because they are important to them. 에반에센스 is my favourite rock band. I have listened to other songs from various rock bands and they are all fascinating- as always. Nevertheless, 에반에센스 is always going to be my favourite of all and that's because of their messages, meanings and the lyrics. The songs are so lyrical and poetic, so beautiful. Lyrics that make tortured people identify with. They help them express and pull out their pain, sorrow, depression.
Although I am an 에반에센스 fan, I don't know even the half of their songs myself. I know only a few, but from those few that I know, I can surely figure out that this is a band that has many things to say, and even 더 많이 people to help. These songs have helped me a lot during tough periods and I can always relate to them. Aside all those, Amy Lee's voice is just stunning! In the recordings of the studio versions she is simply astonishing and the only excuse to say that she is not a good singer is being deaf. Something that is even 더 많이 underrated than the band itself is the music. The 기타 riffs are spectacular! And if 당신 don't believe me, 검색 it and 당신 will indeed find out what 당신 have been missing all along!
에반에센스 is referred to as 고딕 rock with metal influences. But, apart from all the labels, 에반에센스 is a band that has helped and still helps many people with tormented souls. Depression is a recurring theme of the band and depression -as a mental illness is highly linked with finding yourself. People with depression can actually perceive many 더 많이 things than we can. Things with meanings. And even the people who haven't experienced similar pain can understand that the songs have deep meanings from the lyrics. I would never have expected that I would be here now, 글쓰기 such a long argument about why 에반에센스 is so fascinating, since I always took it for granted. I dare haters of the band to read the lyrics and try to understand the meaning first and not to jump to conclusions just from one/ two songs they have heard just to indulge their prejudged notion about the band!
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
next question »