Who do 당신 think would win in a fight out of? (PLease answer the 질문 truthfully, taking into consideration all aspects of fighting e.g. 읽기 minds) 투표 Results - Edward vs Harry

What do you think? Place your vote!

(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)

Edward vs Harry Who do 당신 think would win in a fight out of? (PLease answer the 질문 truthfully, taking into consideration all aspects of fighting e.g. 읽기 minds)

197 fans picked:

해리 포터

72%

에드워드 컬렌

28%

allisoncarleton posted over a year ago

Make your pick! | next poll >>

53 comments

	LilysLittleTwin picked 해리 포터: Sure, Edward could read his mind, I'll admit that, but can dear Eddikins BLOCK the spells? Does he KNOW what they DO? I think not. posted over a year ago.

	TeamSiriusBlack picked 해리 포터: All Harry has to do is Avada Kedavra. Edward can't block that and he'll die. He can't even make a Horcrux because he has no soul. posted over a year ago.

	Renesmee_XD picked 에드워드 컬렌: Edward can doge the spells run fast then do remember Avada Kedvra is for the Wizards and Witches You cant kill a dead person posted over a year ago.

	abitofaLunaTic picked 해리 포터: Harry could use Petrificus Totallus, and then burn Edward posted over a year ago.

	iandamonfan picked 해리 포터: There are so many ways... at least until Stephenie Meyer doesn't say that because they're supernatural creatures spells won't do anything to Edward... which is lame since there are supernatural creatures in HP and the spells work on them. But I repeat, until she says magic doesn't affect vampirers I believe Harry will win. How come no one ever asked her that? It'd be good for the supposed Meyer/Rowling "rivalry"... posted over a year ago.

	ravynflyte picked 해리 포터: Harry could whoop Edward's glittery fairy butt anyday. Bwahahaha! :D posted over a year ago.

	TeamSiriusBlack picked 해리 포터: One Spell: Incendio. One other Spell: Fiendfyre (cursed fire) posted over a year ago.

	ToyletGnome picked 해리 포터: You can't dodge fiendfyre. Also, Edward could never jump high enough to get Harry if he was on a broom. posted over a year ago.

	this-is-my-name picked 해리 포터: One word- magic. posted over a year ago.

	-Alohomora- picked 해리 포터: Harry could also use Occumlency (sp?) to shield his mind from Edward. posted over a year ago.

	tbone_21 picked 에드워드 컬렌: a one-on-one fight would end badly for potter because he casts a spell Edward runs behind him and...SNAP! Potter dead.... Also people are not thinking over how they would fight echother they simply go with wich books they like or read first I like HP 2 but I see both sides posted over a year ago. last edited over a year ago

	Aquilia picked 해리 포터: ^ Ok. So Edward runs, but how will he counter when Harry Disapparates the moment Edward vanishes. Remember, Apparition is as instantaneous in these distances as Edward's speediness. Three spells: Area effective Immobulus (freezing charm) Impedimenta (The Impediment jinx, if you're as skilled as Madam Hooch, you could throw it on two persons almost simultaneously, impeding the progress of two objects/persons at once) And of course, the Area effective Fiendfyre (I would say it's kind of a huge blaze with it's own mind, actively seeking out and destroying anything and everything flammable) Being Area effective, they do not require a hit to be effective as it affects the targets enviroment and everything in it, which would seriously impede Edward as he slows down to a mere 5 metres per second from a Freezing charm. Sidenote: Only goodness knows what these spells may do if cast by the master of the Elder Wand and with the Elder Wand. Last time I checked - Huge massive friggin spoiler - Harry James Potter is the holder and master of the Elder Wand. posted over a year ago. last edited over a year ago

	shivers-zimmy picked 에드워드 컬렌: He Can't Die! Edward Cullen Hands Down! :) posted over a year ago.

	chocoholicarmen picked 해리 포터: Harry, because he defeated Lord Voldemort... when he was ONE year old. And then again. And again. Some sparkling bit of granite is not much in comparison to an almost-immortal powerful dark wizard. posted over a year ago.

	ashan0627 picked 에드워드 컬렌: edward can read his mind and he can only die my being torned into pieces and being burned posted over a year ago.

	Twilimpian picked 에드워드 컬렌: Edward could read his mind, react faster and if he used a spell to burn him it wouldn't work because you'd have to be torn into pieces first. So of course Edward would win. Though I'd like to see Harry try. =) posted over a year ago. last edited over a year ago

	egyptprincess7 picked 해리 포터: Harry all the way and u should Know Why By Now posted over a year ago.

	EalasaidWooster picked 해리 포터: I think we've got ourselves a stalemate here. :) But (and I am NOT just saying this because I prefer Harry Potter) I think Harry has got a better chance. He could tie Edward up, use Sectumsempra to cut hi up, then set him on fire. I know Eddykins is "impossibly fast", but there is a spell (impedimenta, perhaps?) that slows you down. I rest my case. :P posted over a year ago.

	Faith-Rulz picked 해리 포터: hehehe...be one good bloody fight lol posted over a year ago.

	IzzyOzera picked 해리 포터: um hasnt harry learnt to block people out of his mind? just saying plus if he goes accio broomstick im sure he can chase edward and then go AVADA KEDAVRA :) posted over a year ago.

	LifesGoodx3 picked 해리 포터: Avada Kedavra and he wins. Simple as that. posted over a year ago.

	KishuandIchigo picked 해리 포터: Sectumsempra posted over a year ago.

	Renarimae picked 해리 포터: Well I have ten reasons why Harry would win against Edward. First, there's occulemency. Second, I don't think Edward understands Latin so he wouldn't know what the spells do. Third, the only person Avada Kedavra can't work on is Harry. Fourth, Harry has a broom and even though Edward is fast, he can't fly. Fifth, Edward would have four spells against him; Impedimenta, Sectumsempra, Lacarnum Inflamare, and Avada Kedavra. Sixth, Sure Edward can run fast, but he's no Sonic the Hedgehog. Seventh, Edward would have to be as fast as Sonic the Hedgehog to dodge a spell, since it's supposed to be like a light. Eighth, Edward hesitates before finally attacking his foes. Ninth, Edward can die, not naturally, but he can still be killed. Tenth, much of why Stephenie Meyer says Edward would kill Harry in 0.01 seconds is because she has too big of an ego to realize what advantages Harry has that Edward doesn't. posted over a year ago.

	Angel-Trix picked 해리 포터: Occulemcy people That's right, the ability to block your mind. Something Harry can master before he faces and kills Edward's sparkly arse. Also, Harry doesn't need a wand, he can do wandless magic. Lastly, Harry can disapparate. Ten times faster than super speed. posted over a year ago. last edited over a year ago

	DracoLuver picked 해리 포터: I dunno why people say, "Edward can read minds." Has Eddy gone to HOgwarts? NO. Harry will think, "I'm going to use FiendFyre." Not, "I am going to use a massive fire that will burn and chase him." Edward has NO idea what he's thinking. posted over a year ago.

	xcrazygirlx318 picked 해리 포터: Harry could use the Imperious curse! That would control Edward: then he could use Cruciatus, to have him begging for mercy, and then use two other spells to tear him to pieces and rip him up! (vicious mind) lol posted over a year ago.

	HGshipper picked 해리 포터: Harry of course ! posted over a year ago.

	cherry_UK picked 해리 포터: Sure, Edward can't die. But the death is another adventure. Harry is not afraid of it, but, Edward is. So............ Harry is definitely the best!!!!! :D posted over a year ago.

	smallypuppy22 picked 해리 포터: harry can't kill edward whit avada kedavra but harry can use fiendfyre on edward and Edward will die easily, by the way edward can't read harry's mind because harry can block it with occlumency. and harry also can paralyze edward with petrificus totalus or can torture edward with crucio before killing edward with fiendfyre, and other thing harry can call his broom with accio and yes edward is fast but he can't fly. And those are my reasons why I think that harry will totally win in a fight againgst edward. HP the best. posted over a year ago. last edited over a year ago

	princess829 picked 해리 포터: Harry defo posted over a year ago.

	SpeedyGonzalez picked 해리 포터: Lets assume that the killing curse does not affect Edward Cullen. Harry can use imperio and make Edward commit suicide. It is probable that it would hit Edward because spells are described as light so it would travel at he speed of light. posted over a year ago. last edited over a year ago

	pinklover123 picked 에드워드 컬렌: Edward would totally win the fight- duh posted over a year ago.

	Lord-Voldemort picked 해리 포터: I like the idea of Imperiusing him! Absolutely brilliant! Or he could Imperio another vampire! He could make Edward go the big bad Volturi and take his shirt off in the sun XD posted over a year ago. last edited over a year ago

	theighthorcrux picked 해리 포터: Harry Potter, duh. Sectumsempra repeatedly to cut him to pieces and a spell to set them on fire. Although I do like the Imperius curse idea-there are so many ways to kill him.(: posted over a year ago.

	Wotcher_Harry picked 해리 포터: ^^^ That's what i was going to say :D and yeah Edward can read his thoughts but if he hears him say SectumSempra, he'll just be like... WTF? posted over a year ago.

	STLOVER picked 해리 포터: One 5 letter word, M-A-G-I-C!!!!!! posted over a year ago.

	ColieAnne91 picked 에드워드 컬렌: Edward cause he has speed & he can read minds so he knows when to dodge the spells & he can catch Harry when he runs. but i still like Harry but he would lose this fight. posted over a year ago.

	jaynewong picked 해리 포터: hello? harry can do occlumency! edward cant posted over a year ago.

	misukikoyama picked 해리 포터: duh harry potter rules vampires anyday anytime i mean he defeated voldemort for pete's sake he has the elder wand and knows thousands of spells plus he has more fans than mr edward besides robert isn't even that cute i don't know what the big deal is. posted over a year ago.

	graystone picked 해리 포터: So little eddy can read minds,so what?seriously no offense to eddy,but this is one fight u just cant win posted over a year ago.

	lilcherrywine picked 해리 포터: Apparition is faster than Running, btw... Twihards, did you know this? posted over a year ago.

	BlessedByNyx picked 해리 포터: Oh please, Edwards stupid mind reading trick can be easily blocked by Occulumency! And even if by some dumb luck he dodges Avada Kadevra (because no one is Avada Kadevra proof, not even his granite sparkly skin), Fiendfyre is sure to deep fry his sparkly butt extra crispy!! And since when is running an option in front of a wand!! And dude, if you have any backbone Eddy you wouldn't go for snapping necks from behind, face him out front and fight him like a man (if you are one)!! posted over a year ago. last edited over a year ago

	cassie-1-2-3 picked 에드워드 컬렌: Edward dodges the spell Now what? posted over a year ago.

	bdavis98 picked 해리 포터: harry defated the most powerfull and evil wizard,edward need his family to defet a vampire who by standers a pretty normal vampire so i'm gonna say harry + harry has been fighting & winning big battles since he was 11 years old edward is 200 years old or something and he couldn't defet one lossy vampire posted over a year ago.

	sayou picked 해리 포터: tis like duuuuhh posted over a year ago.

	7bella3 picked 에드워드 컬렌: Vampire Vs Wizard = Wizard wins Vampire can read minds and hot vs Wizard = Vampire wins Serosily do the maths! Harry:NOW I SHALL KILL U!! Edward:.... Edward reads Harrys mind Harry in his mind:Oh maybe ill lift him up and throw him in a tree,Whengardenaliusoa!(i know it isnt the real spellin but i cant rember it) Edward runz away and comes behind and kills harry and gets his wand and becomes the famouse wizard :) posted over a year ago.

	ariba_c picked 해리 포터: ^He would think of the spel he is going to use, not the effect of it. Plus, as a ton of the other comments said, he can do occlumency!!! That way Edward cant read his mind. What now? posted over a year ago.

	ginny_potter picked 해리 포터: edward will b on the floor only by "stupefy" posted over a year ago.

	rohehage92 picked 해리 포터: come is dat is a ques now? Everyone knows wus gonna win nd i agree the abv cmmnts. posted over a year ago.

	spellpatronus picked 해리 포터: Petrificus Totalus Sectimsempra Incendio HARRY WINS! ESPECIALY SINCE HE HAS THE ELDER WAND! posted over a year ago.

	wishey picked 해리 포터: There is no way Edward can win. posted over a year ago.

	liana99 picked 에드워드 컬렌: Edward is immortal¨:P He runs fast he has got a lot of strength.. Harry is just a wizard and he's not immortal posted over a year ago.

	mrsniallhoran93 picked 해리 포터: Obviously, Harry would win. posted over a year ago.