Critical Analysis of Twilight

이 질문에 답하기

Critical Analysis of Twilight 질문

Hey, kittens! Momcat would like your input on this! :)

'Ello, kitties! Dearheart here! (And no, I didn't give myself the oh-so-clever 제목 of "momcat". It was given to me 의해 the wonderful Myf_1992, so give her the 사랑 for that. You're awesome, Myf!) =)

Anyway, I've been debating with myself for a while about whether 또는 not this video would go against the spirit of CAT 또는 not.

link

Please, don't feel like 당신 have to watch it. I'm just providing a link for any curious 고양이 here. =)

In my opinion, this is a very funny anti-Twilight rant. The gal has a fun, sarcastic, clever sense of humor, she's cute, and she's very articulate. However, at the end of the video, she has "bonus footage" of her destroying a copy of Twilight. No, there's no book burning...she mostly just rips out the pages in various ways. Hehe.

But the CAT rules say that no 비디오 with "Twilight carnage" are allowed to be submitted.

But...it's such a funny rant... =(

Anyway, I'm not going to 제출하기 it (unless 당신 guys think providing a link in the 질문 counts as submitting it...in which case, if anyone has a problem with that, let me know. I'm perfectly willing to take out the link).

What I want to know is what 당신 would do. If it were up to you, would 당신 제출하기 it here despite the book-demolition at the end, 또는 would 당신 just leave it alone? I'm curious. As I've said before, the rules do have some wiggle room. How would 당신 handle it?

(Bleh, that was a ridiculously long-winded question...sorry...) XD
 Dearheart posted over a year ago
next question »

Critical Analysis of Twilight 답변

Sappp said:
Type it.

Lots of work mbut that way 당신 could evade the book-destroying thing AND have the rant on this spot.


 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
Myf_1992 said:
Thank 당신 XD your awesome too(well, duh! I don't need to say it because everyone knows your awesome)!

I think I would find out if there was a way to 편집 the video, i.e. cut out the book destruction.

If not then I'd post the video, and give a warning in the 설명 saying at the end there is book destruction, please ignore. But before doing that I would probably consult you. And should there be a problem then I would remove it.

I don't think giving a link in a 질문 counts as submitting a video.

So yer that's what I would do. I hope this helped in your 토론 against yourself. I hate debating against myself, because I'm always right, and if I'm debating with myself, in order to be right, I have to be wrong, at that just hurts my head. ((:
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
snoznoodle said:
That's such a great video!! She's so funny!
I don't know if it's a good idea to 제출하기 though unless 당신 can 편집 it 또는 put a disclaimer of some sort in the description. I don't like the 책 anymore and I didn't really like watching the destruction. It was kind of funny actually I was thinking that poor book! And then trying to think of everything she would be ruining and then not caring as much.
I don't think 팬 would appreciate it though.
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
katiecain said:
I haven't watched the video yet (I just really can't be bothered atm, I'm sorry XD) but if it involves destroying it then I would say 당신 should go with the rules. They're there for a reason, 팬 would definately dislike it and I have no problems with rants/reasons why people dislike Twilight but destroying the 책 is kinda pointless and immature in my opinion. I don't think there's anything wrong with posting the link here though, you've clearly stated what it involves and I wouldn't count it as submitting it. =)
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
tammy63 said:
I 사랑 this video! It's the funniest one I've seen in a while! Thanks for letting us know about it! My only nitpick was her poor attempt to destroy the book, i wanted a public book burning!
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
next question »
Cookies help us bring you Fanpop. By using Fanpop, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More Got It!