Are 당신 tired of Beastly being compared to Twilight? 투표 Results - Beastly (Film)

What do you think? Place your vote!

(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)

Beastly (Film) Are 당신 tired of Beastly being compared to Twilight?

77 fans picked:

Hell YES! The stories are completely different!

91%

No, I compare Twilight to every teen romance story.

Eggie30 posted over a year ago

Make your pick! | next poll >>

30 comments

	ForsakenMoon19 said: Yes I hate the comparison but to be honest it doesn't bother me, only on the scale when ppl make it a bigger deal then it is. I like both books, they're similar and different at the same time and the target readers/audiences for Twilight is the same for BEASTLY!!! That being said I love BEASTLY wayyyyyy more than the Twilight saga!!:D posted over a year ago.

	Eggie30 said: Well, for someone like me who doesn't like Twilight, the constant comparisons are annoying. The stories are completely different and so are the main characters. There are other teen romance stories out there that could be compared to Beastly besides Twilight. But yet, no one seems to mention them. posted over a year ago.

	ForsakenMoon19 said: People compare everything to Twilight because they think it's an unbeatable pheneomenon, which is really annoying!!! Look at all the crap they've been saying about the Vampire Diaries, thoes books were out long before Twilight and thoes Twihards are all saying its a rip off. How can something that's been out since the 90s, be a rip off???? Beastly is getting compared now because there are certain similarities to Twilight, like the whole supernatural teen romance about a girl falling love with a monster. They aren't really looking at a "Beauty and the Beast" revision, which is what it is only better!! And anyway i can't really stand twilight these days, its not the best book series out there! sorry for the ramble, lol posted over a year ago.

	Eggie30 said: It bothers me that Twilight is like the benchmark for all teen romances. Any new supernatural teen romance book or film that comes out is immediately compared to Twilight. Even if the story is not similar to Twilight. To me, the only things Beastly has in common with Twilight are that it's a teen romance and the hero is a monster. But Kyle is nothing like Edward, and Linda is nothing like Bella. And there are no vampires or werewolves in Beastly. I've read Beastly and the entire Twilight series. I enjoyed Beastly, but was not impressed with Twilight. You're right about The Vampire Diaries. Those books were out way before Stephenie wrote Twilight. Some Twihards are just ignorant and don't do their homework before they make comments. posted over a year ago.

	ForsakenMoon19 said: Glad you agree with me there!! there are other things out there way better than Twilight and I think things like Beastly and the Vampire Diaries are way more interesting!! Like you i was also disappointed in the saga, just wasn't my thing by the time i got around to reading the crap that is breaking dawn!!! now Twilight may have paved the way for these other teen supernatural romances to become known but its not the be all and end all!!! BTW i'm really enjoying our discussion here:) posted over a year ago.

	xoKel_Belxo picked Hell YES! The stories are completely different!: its Beastly!! hence Beauty and the Beast...i mean..its a tale as old as time, and yet twilighters are saying its a poser,and they're coping twilight...i mean Beauty and the Beast(the story) is wayy older then stephine meyer...so i just dont understand it... posted over a year ago. last edited over a year ago

	Eggie30 said: You're right. How can Beastly be a poser when it's based on a story that was out wayyy before Twilight? Some Twihards are just stupid. posted over a year ago.

	ForsakenMoon19 said: At the moment these twihard idiots (no ofense) are saying everything has copied Twilight from Buffy, to the Wolfman, to Anne Rice, to Daybreakers etc. the list continues and if you think this is bad READ this: link posted over a year ago.

	Eggie30 said: OMG! Kayla just proved my point about the stupidity of some Twihards. Hahaha! Her email was so stupid it's hilarious. Thanks for sharing. posted over a year ago.

	ForsakenMoon19 said: LOL thought you'd get a kick out of that:D As soon as i read it my jaw dropped and i wanted to smack that chic the side of the head, the girl needs it because that has got to be the dumbest complaint I've ever heard from any fan!!! posted over a year ago.

	QueenVictoria73 picked Hell YES! The stories are completely different!: i agree, STFU, lol posted over a year ago.

	Faith-Rulz picked Hell YES! The stories are completely different!: omg i just read what that chick wrote - lol i think she needs to crack open and read some other books other than twilight and read some of the REAL classics for crying out loud lol..btw u made my day ForsakenMoon, ta for sharing that :) posted over a year ago.

	rubberduck2 picked Hell YES! The stories are completely different!: i just arrived in this club and the first 5 picks were all about Beastly vs Twilight, i think they should just stop comparing twilight to well anything, twilight is in its own messed up league posted over a year ago.

	silverwarrior picked Hell YES! The stories are completely different!: i dont gat why people have to compare EVERYTHING to twilight. I read the series, and i thought they were perfectly fine, but all the talk about and comparing it to EVERYTHING is gettin REALLY annoying! posted over a year ago.

	dustfinger picked Hell YES! The stories are completely different!: Yes Beastly is nothing like Twilight posted over a year ago.

	BleedingLove picked Hell YES! The stories are completely different!: I totally agree with everyone!! Just because "Beastly" is about teenagers who fell in love it is not like "Twilight" People compare nearly everything with "Twilight" This is really annoying!!!! posted over a year ago. last edited over a year ago

	Triscia95 said: Dude i didn't know that. people need to stop comparing every fictional movie to Twilight. posted over a year ago.

	zanesaaomgfan said: Since was Twilight compared to Beastly? posted over a year ago.

	carly-hope picked Hell YES! The stories are completely different!: yeah, they have very little in common posted over a year ago.

	Elizabeth_Darcy said: I don't see why Beastly and Twilight are being compared; I love both stories, but they are not the same! Why would they be compared to each other, when they have very little in common? posted over a year ago. last edited over a year ago

	Magy6 picked Hell YES! The stories are completely different!: I agree with ForsakenMoon19. I loved Twilight when I first read it but then I read so many better books and now it's just annoying to see this one fall in Twilight's shadow just like for example The Vampire Diaries, Vampire Academy(which is so much better than Twilight that I don't even know how to describe it)and now Beastly. posted over a year ago.

	ForsakenMoon19 said: I love Vampire Academy awesome series and Beastly is amazing!! Another new series you guys should check out which is totally nothing like twilight is I AM NUMBER FOUR starring Beastly's own Alex Pettyfer!!! But seriously the first book is awesome and can't wait for the sequel which comes out in August, then of course we gotta wait for the second movie ahhhhh, getting ahead of myself lol!!! Botton line BEASTLY is absolutely NOTHING like twilight!!!! posted over a year ago.

	kalfire1 picked Hell YES! The stories are completely different!: How is beastly like twilight? Really? posted over a year ago.

	Harrypotter148 picked Hell YES! The stories are completely different!: I am soo sick of twilight Sure sure its a ok book but its not the besy and stop comparing it to EVERYTHING posted over a year ago.

	Ginevraaa picked Hell YES! The stories are completely different!: Besides this is the Beastly spot. If you want to compare these two just make your own spot named Beastly vs Twilight! posted over a year ago.

	gaby14 picked Hell YES! The stories are completely different!: mostly every club i go to TWILGHT SAGA is ALWAYS IN THERE COME ON STOP COMPARING WITH THE TWILIGHT SAGA!! posted over a year ago.

	Britneys1Fan said: If Vanessa Hudgens isn't in Beastly, it'll be already better without Vanessa Hudslut!!! My opinion. :) Beastly and Twilight are both great movies. :) But I only wish if it hads Vanessa Hudslut's replacement already! Vanessa Hudslut acting, ruined the movie!!! posted over a year ago.

	TheDevilsDuches picked Hell YES! The stories are completely different!: I'm sick of Twilight vs. Beastly make a spot for that posted over a year ago.

	Kim_Grint picked No, I compare Twilight to every teen romance story.: I love both films. Beastly is a different story, but they do have their similarities. Edward is quite hot, but is Kyle. posted over a year ago.

	hatelarxene picked Hell YES! The stories are completely different!: Beastly is just a modern version of Beauty and the Beast, which is a beautiful story to begin with. Twilight is nothing but a story about abuse between two extremely boring people (and another extremely dull other guy, but whatever). posted over a year ago.