이 질문에 답하기

Atheism 질문

What's the difference between atheist and agnotic?

 Cabutchikas posted over a year ago
next question »

Atheism 답변

misanthrope86 said:
Well, everyone has their own opinion on what the differences are, but essentially Agnostics claim that they do not know 또는 cannot know about the exsistence of God. Atheists, on the other hand, deny the exsistence of God. That is, they claim that a God is not possible.

That is just a very, VERY bare-bones basic outline of the difference between them. Like organised religions, these two 'philiophies' (or whatever 당신 want to call them) are interpreted differently 의해 different people.

Great question, 의해 the way. Lots of people are confused 의해 what these words mean. I don't always see a distinction, whereas sometimes the distinctions are obvious.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
bRiNnAyCuLlEn said:
What I thought it was was that Atheists do not in any way believe in any god, but that Agnostics just aren't sure and don't really care whether there is 또는 not.

Now what I'm told is that Atheists (^ see above), but Agnostics believe there is a god, but don't know who he is and don't really care.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
ruby1000 said:
Agnostic: They believe that there might be a god 또는 a higher being but it can not be decided nor defined as something like christianity, but a god is possible.

Atheist: There is no god 또는 higher being.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
Lord-Voldemort said:
As Richard Dawnkins puts it, an atheist thinks something along the lines of "the existence of God is hightly improbable and I live my life on the assumption that he doesn't exist" whereas an agnostic "concedes that there is an equal proabability of God existing 또는 not existing."

또는 as my friend Trix eloquently puts it, atheists don't believe, agnostics don't care.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
KateKicksAss said:
I've actually heard agnostics being described a few different ways.
I've always thought of agnostics as people who aren't sure whether god exists 또는 not. Not necessarily not caring, as the other people have said, but as just unsure, basically they don't have any proof to go either way.
I've also heard them described as being equally accepting of there being a god as there not being a god. Fairly similar to what I've described above, but the same person also described atheists as being completely certain that there is NOT a god.
I disagree with that 설명 of an atheist and an agnostic though, since everyone else i've talked to has said atheists just don't believe in god, not necessarily being 100% sure there isn't one.
I've also heard it said that agnostics are polite atheists, which doesn't seem necessarily true.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
I was raised agnostic, and I agree that agnostics aren't sure. However, the majority of atheists don't KNOW that there isn't a God, they suspect and live on the assumption that he doesn't exist.
Lord-Voldemort posted over a year ago
smirktastic said:
Gnostic/agnostic and theist/atheist are different facets of the religious/spiritual spectrum. However, gnostic/agnostic and theist/atheist are not mutually exclusive.

Gnosticism means that, whether 당신 are theist 또는 atheist, 당신 believe that 당신 know what 당신 believe is true. Agnostic means 당신 believe that 당신 don't know what 당신 believe is true.

Theism is the belief in a deity 또는 deities of some kind, and atheism is technically anything that is not an express belief in any deities, though it generally refers to having an express disbelief in any deities.

That means that people who say they do not know if they believe in god 또는 not are technically atheists, and they would have to believe that they couldn't know if there is a god, whether 또는 not they could decide what they believed, to be agnostic.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
twilightlover73 said:
As Richard Dawkins said, there's 더 많이 than one type of agnostics.
But it's mainly just someone who doesn't know (believe) whether there is a God 또는 not. Some don't care, others just don't know. Some guess, and others rely on 50/50 probability.
While an Atheist is someone who simply does not believe in God.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
dadadas said:
Well, atheist strongly believe that there is no God and agnostic believe God may and may not exist.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
next question »