I think my first 아니메 crush was Sonic the Hedgehog from Sonic X. (Don't judge me! XD) I just thought he was adorable. Sonic X IS an anime, and was the first 아니메 that I was willing to watch all episodes of.
다음 was Fruits Basket, what got me even 더 많이 into anime. Yuki Sohma was my first human 아니메 crush. XD
This is pretty weird when 당신 compare to the 더 많이 obvious choices in Fruits Basket...but Shigure Sohma, strangely enough, despite his pervertedness. His voice sounds all weird in the 아니메 though. I'd got so used to imagining him in the 망가 I totally wasn't expecting the 아니메 to be so different...I think I like him because he's funny most of all.